#1 2008-07-24 13:52:00

Chabako
New Member
Ranking
Registered: 2008-07-24
Posts: 2
Reputation :  [+ 0/ -0 ]
Expertise

Differences between Omotesenke and Urasenke.

Hello everyone,

I haven't decided whether to study Urasenke or Omotesenke, so I've struggled to look up some differences (and when I mean struggle, I mean that there is almost no information on how these two schools are different.)
Anyways, here are some of the differences, but if you know of any more, PLEASE ADD TO THE LIST!!

-It seems that Urasenke has almost twice as many certificates than Omotesenke, however, they take about the same time to reach the lowest level of "teacher" status (10 years).

-The Urasenke tradition stirs its tea so that a lot of "froth" covers the surface of the tea, while the Omotesenke tradition leaves a small "jade lake" in the center.

-The Urasenke tradition uses an untreated whisk, while the Omotesenke tradition uses a darkened whisk.

-There are more temae positions in Urasenke than in Omotesenke.

-Omotesenke almost never uses fukusa that are patterned or have different designs, whereas the Urasenke tradition allows for the use of patterned fukusa.

-The Omotesenke tradition tends to be more conservative, whereas the Urasenke tradition tends to be more open to new things (Urasenke was the inventor of Ryurei, which was then copied and assimilated by the other two main tea schools.)

Last edited by Chabako (2008-08-02 10:43:50)

Offline

 

#2 2008-08-01 08:51:46

sweetpersimmon
Member
RankingRanking
From: Portland, OR
Registered: 2007-08-01
Posts: 19
Reputation :  [+ 2/ -0 ]
Website  Expertise

Re: Differences between Omotesenke and Urasenke.

You probably cannot find much written about the differences between the two schools because once you start on the path it is difficult to change and then compare the two.  I have studied Urasenke for more than 25 years but have been to Omotesenke chakai so I cannot tell you much about the differences between the two.  Mostly, I think they are stylistic differences like you just mentioned.  The philosophy, history and aesthetics are very similar, as of course they both have descended from the Sen Family line.

I think the important thing is not to choose the school based on the differences, but to find a teacher who you respect and feel comfortable studying with for a long long time.  If you have a teacher you like, it will not matter how many certificates you have, nor the number of temae positions you learn. If you wish to reach teacher status in a 7-10 years you will work very hard indeed, no matter which school you choose.

As for the rumor of Urasenke showing off expensive utensils, I think that is not true. The Urasenke tradition is wabi cha.  We are taught that the sincerity of your heart is more important than utensils.

Please ask more questions if you think of any and I will try to answer.

sweetpersimmon

Offline

 

#3 2008-08-03 20:28:26

Chabako
New Member
Ranking
Registered: 2008-07-24
Posts: 2
Reputation :  [+ 0/ -0 ]
Expertise

Re: Differences between Omotesenke and Urasenke.

Thank you for your reply. It says on your profile that you studied Urasenke in Kyoto. Did you have to pay for your trip and stay or are there "scholarships" that help defray the costs?

Thanks!

Offline

 

#4 2008-08-03 22:20:14

sweetpersimmon
Member
RankingRanking
From: Portland, OR
Registered: 2007-08-01
Posts: 19
Reputation :  [+ 2/ -0 ]
Website  Expertise

Re: Differences between Omotesenke and Urasenke.

I was there about 12 years ago. At that time you had to be referred by your sensei, and then go through an application process that took about a year.  The application process includes a personal essay, 3 community recommendations, visa application and other requirements.   You had to provide your own airfare and transportation from the Osaka or Nagoya, as Kyoto has no international airport.

When I was there the program was in the process of changing from a 3 year program to a 1 year program.  The three year program provided room and board and you had to pay for other living expenses.  The one year program provided room and board, plus a modest stipend.  I understand the program continues to change.  Ask your sensei to write to Urasenke in Kyoto to find out the current requirements.

sweetpersimmon

P.S. Chabako, Urasenke doesn't usually use patterned fukusa either. You can carry them or give them as gifts, however. 

If you are in California, the Hakone Daichakai will be October 19th.
So far they will have Yabunouchi, Matsuoryu, Mushanokojisenke , Urasenke and Omotesenke schools hosting chakai at different seki. It would be educational to see the different styles of tea.

Last edited by sweetpersimmon (2008-08-06 10:14:29)

Offline

 

#5 2009-02-03 21:14:20

Barbara Nostrand
New Member
Ranking
United States
From: Syracuse, NY
Registered: 2009-02-03
Posts: 7
Reputation :  [+ 0/ -0 ]
Website  Expertise

Re: Differences between Omotesenke and Urasenke.

Hi.

Historically, both Omotesenke and Urasenke were started by the same man. Omotesenke was started first, and after the founding iemoto retired, he gathered together a group of close students and others and founded Urasenke.

Stylistically, there are rather odd differences between the two schools. For example:

The handling of kaishi (paper for sweets) while eating okashi (sweets).

Which way you fold your hands in your lap.

Whether and when you snap your fukusa (a thick silk cloth square which functions as a dust rag) during particular temae (tea making procedures).

To complicate things further, both schools have evolved. So for example, where you place the futaoki (lid rest) in respect to a daisu (a kind of table) or a nagaita (a long lacquer ware board) has changed over time within the Urasenke school. Or, so I was taught by my various sensei.

Offline

 

#6 2009-02-03 21:20:49

Barbara Nostrand
New Member
Ranking
United States
From: Syracuse, NY
Registered: 2009-02-03
Posts: 7
Reputation :  [+ 0/ -0 ]
Website  Expertise

Re: Differences between Omotesenke and Urasenke.

Hi!

sweetpersimmon wrote:

I was there about 12 years ago. At that time you had to be referred by your sensei, and then go through an application process that took about a year.  The application process includes a personal essay, 3 community recommendations, visa application and other requirements.   You had to provide your own airfare and transportation from the Osaka or Nagoya, as Kyoto has no international airport.

I have at various times dreamed of attending the tea school, but have grown old and there is no tea community within 5 hours of here in Syracuse, NY.

Offline

 

#7 2009-02-04 13:32:25

sweetpersimmon
Member
RankingRanking
From: Portland, OR
Registered: 2007-08-01
Posts: 19
Reputation :  [+ 2/ -0 ]
Website  Expertise

Re: Differences between Omotesenke and Urasenke.

Hello Barbara,

I have at various times heard from you on various forums, and it is nice to meet you.  Lucky for us the internet affords a virtual forum like this.   I enjoy a large tea community in Portland Oregon, and I feel for you doing tea in the "wilderness".  Please stop by my blog

sweetpersimmon1.blogspot.com


And if you would like to contribute as a guest blogger about chado, Japanese culture, or anything that comes to mind, please contact me.

Margie

Offline

 

#8 2009-11-24 19:59:24

Nick
New Member
Ranking
Registered: 2009-11-24
Posts: 7
Reputation :  [+ 0/ -0 ]
Expertise

Re: Differences between Omotesenke and Urasenke.

One consideration might be the relative difficulty of finding Omotesenke teachers outside Japan.  In large US cities you may have less trouble, but in general Urasenke has spread more.

The differences between the schools are quite small really.  Besides some of the other things mentioned above, some other differences include the way you rise from a seiza position; which foot is used to enter and leave the tea room; and how the fukusa is handled and folded. 

All other things being equal (foremost being access to a teacher), I don't think it particularly matters which style you choose to study, since the basic purpose of tea is the same, and only the small details differ (and even then, often they don't differ very much).

Offline

 

Board footer

OPML feedsRSS feeds



Powered by WWWThreads Forum
© Copyright 2006, WWWThreads